New Place - Journal

Artwork for 'I Love You So Much': a flowering vine in a pink and teal frame on a dark background, after Johannes Hartlieb's Book of Herbs.

Anthology 4: I Love You so Much

I Love You So Much was a song which Reuben presented to us on the same band call which The Mire was debuted on.

Back then it was called Nervous World. It was calm and mellow the whole way through, more of a gentle guitar ballad than anything else. It was just Reuben, some guitars, and a synth pattern repeatedly falling throughout. The vocals were double tracked, but asynchronously. Reuben didn’t have the first vocal take playing when he sang the second one, so the two takes fall out of time with each other and twist around the same basic melody with different ornaments. The result embraces a more imperfect approach to vocals.

The kernel of the song was essentially all there. The whole track is really that phrase, ‘I love you so much’, gaining and losing meaning with each repetition. Reuben wrote it while he was at university, and it’s dedicated to close friends, but it’s neither totally romantic nor entirely platonic. At the end of the day it’s about urging the people we love to stay in the world, despite how terrible it can be.

Reuben's Original Demo - October 2022
Loads Google Drive’s player.Open audio in Google Drive

When we brought it into rehearsal, Reuben felt the song should sound like the demo: quiet, steady, no big climax. The band had other ideas. We jammed it through a few times and eventually Kristian suggested a potential dynamic arc for the song as he saw it, with a climax where the quietest part was in the demo.

This new form was simple but brutal. The verses hold back as before, with Zach’s violin threading through them, and then the whole thing climbs. The cacophonous drum solo is collapsing in on itself and the whining guitars pile on top. The inevitable release eventually runs out of steam and settles down again, continuing the same refrain like a mantra. Now it’s quieter, more raw.

Charlie does backing vocals on the record, and Alex mostly plays what Reuben tells him to play, which is an underrated skill in a band. Charlie also overdubbed a small, nearly inaudible piano part that sits under the track for most of its runtime, and only really lets itself be heard near the end in a hopeful arpeggio, soothing the song.

Reuben has said that adapting his songs to a band setting has been a learning process. This one was the clearest example. The original version didn’t want to explode. The band insisted it had to. Reuben resisted it at first but once we tried it, it was clear that that’s what the song really needed to do. It needed to say it loudly (that which isn’t said enough) rather than whisper it.

Lyrically it lives inside the Garden Songs world without trying too hard to prove it. There’s the prolonged drought image, ‘seven long years with no soil’, and the references to worms, but these words predated the Garden Songs theme. It’s not totally clear to us why that line, I love you so much, really repeats that much. Maybe it’s too kitsch, too ‘pop music’. It can lose its honest meaning if not said carefully. But on the other hand, there’s not much more to say than that, is there?

Personnel

Charlie Stevens – Guitar, backing vocals, & piano

Reuben Esterhuizen – Vocals, guitar, lyrics & synth

Alex Queripel – Guitar

Kristian Queripel – Bass

Zach Ellis – Drums & Violin

New Place